7 questions to ask before you hire a marketing agency for your contracting business

Big upfront fees, vague promises and junk leads are the most common ways contractors get burned by agencies. These seven questions help you spot the problems before you sign.

TS
Tanmay Srivastava
· 2 min read

If you've run a home-service business for a while, you've probably paid an agency that promised the world and delivered a handful of leads. It happens a lot. The good news is that most bad agencies show the same warning signs, and you can spot them before you sign.

Ask these seven questions on your next sales call.

1. What do I pay before I see results?

Large upfront fees are the most common way contractors get burned. Some agencies charge several thousand dollars to "set up," deliver very little and then go quiet.

What to look for: a small setup fee that's refundable if they don't deliver.

2. What exactly is written into the contract?

Anyone can promise results on a call. What matters is what ends up in writing.

What to look for: a specific appointment target, a timeframe and a closed-job goal, plus exactly what happens if they miss. If they won't write it down, they don't believe it either.

3. Do you send me leads or appointments?

Leads are names and numbers you have to chase. Appointments are homeowners who have already been spoken to and booked onto your calendar. Read more in our guide to leads vs. qualified appointments.

What to look for: someone on their side calls every lead, screens it and books it.

4. Who talks to my leads?

Some agencies hand your leads to a voice bot. Others expect you to hire and manage your own call center.

What to look for: trained people calling your leads, with AI helping in the background, not replacing the conversation.

5. Do you work with my competitors?

If an agency runs ads for three roofers in the same county, they're competing against themselves for the same homeowners.

What to look for: a limit of one company per trade in each area.

6. Do you take a cut of my revenue?

Revenue-share deals can sound fair until you're handing over a large share of every job, including the ones you'd have won anyway.

What to look for: a clear, flat monthly fee that you can plan around.

7. What can I see every day?

You shouldn't have to wait for a monthly report to know what's happening.

What to look for: a CRM you can log into anytime, with every lead, every call, every appointment and every closed job.

Run your numbers first

Before any call, it helps to know what good looks like for your business. Our ROI calculator shows what a daily ad budget turns into in appointments, sits, closed deals and profit for your trade.

How Forevency answers these questions

  1. A small setup fee, fully refundable.
  2. Appointment target, timeframe and closed-job goal in the contract, or your money back.
  3. Appointments, booked onto your calendar.
  4. Real people on our team call every lead.
  5. One company per trade in each county.
  6. One flat monthly fee. No revenue share.
  7. Our CRM, with your whole pipeline, any time.

If that sounds like the agency you've been looking for, book a growth call.

Frequently asked questions

How much should a contractor pay a marketing agency up front?

As little as possible until results are proven. Be careful with large upfront fees that aren't refundable. A small, refundable setup fee is a sign the agency expects to deliver.

Should a marketing agency guarantee results?

A good agency should be willing to put specific targets in the contract, such as an appointment number, a timeframe and a closed-job goal, along with what happens if they miss.

What is a red flag when hiring a contractor marketing agency?

Large non-refundable fees, no written targets, sending you raw leads to chase, asking for a share of your revenue, and working with your direct competitors in the same area.

Keep reading